Lead-free perovskite solar cells - How fluoride additives improve quality
Fluoride additives increase the quality of the perovskite layer. At BESSY II a team has now explored the chemistry in detail. © M. Künsting/HZB
Tin halide perovskites are currently considered the best alternative to their lead-containing counterparts, which are, however, still significantly less efficient and stable. Now, a team led by Prof. Antonio Abate from HZB has analysed the chemical processes in the perovskite precursor solution and the fluoride compounds in detail. Using a clever combination of measurement methods at BESSY II and with NMR at the Humboldt-University Berlin, they were able to show that fluoride prevents the oxidation of tin and leads to a more homogeneous film formation with fewer defects, increasing the quality of the semiconductor layer.
Lead halide perovskite solar cells promise very high efficiencies at low manufacturing costs. However, the toxicity of lead poses serious environmental concerns, proving the need for lead-free alternatives. Tin is currently considered the best choice, but faces challenges regarding its oxidation and uncontrolled crystallization that restrains the respective solar cells in their production, performance and stability.
Tin fluoride helps
One of the most common strategies to obtain good quality tin-based perovskite thin-films involves the use of tin fluoride (SnF2) as an additive in the solution-based process. The improved optoelectronic and morphological properties of SnF2-containing films have been thoroughly characterised in literature, although the role of this additive remained underexplored.
Chemical behavior explored
Now, a team led by Prof. Antonio Abate has for the first time elucidated the important chemical role of SnF2 inside the perovskite solution that is responsible for these improvements. The key lies in the chemical behaviour of fluoride anions. Tin easily oxidises from Sn(II) to Sn(IV), generating defects in the semiconductor film. Data from nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) analyses now showed that the fluoride anion from SnF2 has a strong affinity for Sn(IV) and forms the compound SnF4. Using hard X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy at BESSY II, the team was able to demonstrate that SnF4 shows a lower tendency to be entrapped in the perovskite structure compared to SnI4, resulting in less Sn(IV) content in the film. Finally, small-angle X-ray scattering measurements at BESSY II revealed that the fluoride appears to positively affect the nucleation process in the precursor solution, which improves crystallisation.
More homogenous crystal growth
"To put it simply, fluoride anions trap oxidized Sn(IV) in the solution, as SnF4. The lower affinity of this material to perovskite-like species prevents its inclusion in the perovskite film," says Jorge Pascual, a postdoc from Abate’s group working on tin halide perovskites. "In addition, fluoride improves the colloid stability of tin halide perovskite precursor solutions, precursor subunits creating a more uniformly distributed oriented attachment, resulting in a more homogeneous crystal growth," explains Marion Flatken, who carried out the research as part of her PhD in the same team.
These results come at the right time. Based on this study, it might be possible to explore other promising additives that further improve the properties of lead-free perovskite solar cells.
- BESSY II: High-resolution insights into individual biomolecules and catalystsVery small biological samples and even individual biomolecules can now be examined under near-physiological conditions with high confidence at the BESSY II infrared beamline with a newly validated and improved technique: The nanoscale infrared spectroscopy (s-SNOM) with ultra-thin silicon-based membranes. An international team demonstrated after an initial proof of concept, that high-resolution (a few tens of nanometres) nano-IR measurements reliably match expected far-field IR spectra in an aqueous environment. This methodological advance provides a solid foundation for studying biomaterials or observing catalytic processes in a liquid environment.
- New method shows how molecular switches are influenced by their neighborsResearchers at Friedrich Schiller University Jena and the Helmholtz Centre Berlin (HZB) have, for the first time, been able to directly observe how the environment surrounding a molecular switch influences its electronic structure. Molecular switches are molecules that can be switched between two states by external influences such as changes in temperature—similar to a switch with the positions »On« and »Off«. Such molecules are being investigated as potential building blocks for future data storage devices or sensor materials. Using magnetic-field-dependent terahertz spectroscopy, the researchers have now, for the first time, been able to distinguish whether neighbouring molecules in a material are in the same or different states. The results have been published in the journal »Angewandte Chemie International Edition«.
- BESSY II is back in operation after maintenance shutdownOn 7 September 2026, BESSY II was set into operation after a four-week shutdown. BESSY II is scheduled to resume full user operation on 22 September.